| 1883 | — | 1884 | Rev. John Anderson |
| 1884 | — | 1892 | Rev. William Chinn |
| 1893 | — | 1896 | Rev. Byron Clark |
| 1898 | — | 1903 | Rev. James H. Henderlite |
| 1903 | — | 1907 | Rev. Peter B. Henderlite |
| 1910 | — | 1915 | Rev. J. W. Lacy |
| 1915 | — | 1917 | Rev. Marion S. Huske |
| 1917 | — | 1919 | Rev. Leighton G. McMillian |
| 1919 | — | 1922 | Rev. Frank M. Bain |
| 1922 | — | 1924 | Rev. Edwin C. Clyde |
| 1924 | — | 1929 | Rev. R. Allen Brown |
| 1929 | — | 1937 | Rev. John W. Bracy |
| 1937 | — | 1942 | Rev. Roscoe Prince |
| 1944 | — | 1948 | Rev. John A. Bowman |
| 1949 | — | 1957 | Rev. George M. Apperson, Jr. |
| 1958 | — | 1961 | Rev. Walter Ward White |
| 1962 | — | 1966 | Rev. C. Graham Reid, Jr. |
| 1966 | — | 1969 | Rev. Edgar C. Mayse |
| 1970 | — | 1971 | Rev. Harold H. Cummings |
| 1972 | — | 1972 | Rev. Jan Gaylord Owen |
| 1974 | — | 1990 | Rev. William M. Plonk |
| 1990 | — | 1991 | Rev. Dr. Donald R. Broad
|
| 1991 | — | 7/01/00 | Rev. Dr. Elizabeth B. Talbot |
| 7/1/00 | — | 7/1/01 | Rev. Dr. Donald
R. Broad
|
| 7/1/01 | — | 12/31/02 | Rev. Dr. William D. Carmines |
| 1/1/03 | — | 2/22/04 | Rev.
Dr. Donald R. Broad
|
| 9/15/04 |
— |
7/31/06 |
Rev. Dr. Eugene
Soud (interim) |
| 9-1-06 | — | Rev. Dr. Robert M.
Close |
|